ANNE
HUTCHINSON:
THE MOST IMPORTANT ENGLISH WOMAN IN COLONIAL AMERICA
Anne
Hutchinson’s legacy has changed over the last 300 years.
To the Puritan
orthodoxy of the 16th Century, she was an “agent of
destructive anarchy.” To the 19th Century, Anne was a crusader for
religious liberty. In our time, she is the symbol of a feminist leader;
assertive and highly visible.
Anne Marbury was born in
Lincolnshire, England, in 1591. She was the daughter of an Anglican minister
with Puritan inclinations; so much so that he was censured and imprisoned. At
21, Anne married a merchant working in London named William Hutchinson. Shortly
afterward, the couple moved to the small town of Alford to start a family. They
had heard of a young, charismatic Puritan minister named Rev.
John Cotton who was preaching
in a nearby town and decided to attend his service. Although Cotton was only
27, he was gaining a reputation for giving spiritual messages that were unlike
any others. He minimized an individual’s behavior as a requirement to gain
salvation while emphasizing one’s spiritual conversion. Anne was greatly drawn
to this message, and she attended his church often. Cotton’s philosophy was
called the “COVENANT OF GRACE” and differed from mainstream Puritan teachings,
the “COVENANT OF WORKS.”
The
“Covenant of Works” vs. the “Covenant of Grace”
A theological “covenant”
is a divinely offered agreement or promise from God that frames His
relationship with humanity. At the time, two different theological covenants
vied for acceptance. The first, supported by the more orthodox Puritan sects,
was the “Covenant
of Works,” sometimes called the old covenant, which is a major theme
of the Old Testament. It supports the belief that salvation is achieved by
following the laws set down by God. It promises eternal life for obedience and
death for disobedience. Signs of the Covenant of Works include the knowledge of
good and evil and the observance of the Sabbath.
The second is the “Covenant of
Grace,” sometimes called the new covenant. It is the primary message
of the New Testament. It supports the belief that salvation is achieved through
the crucifixion of Christ which atones for the sins of all who put their faith
in him; Christ being the representative for all mankind. Signs of the Covenant
of Grace include Baptism and Communion. Some people believe it replaces the
Covenant of Works, but most see it as existing alongside it. Other theological
covenants, not related to salvation, also exist such as belief in a “promised
land.”
(We are not theologians,
and admit that the understanding of covenants is much deeper than this brief
description. But we are looking at the historical and sociological consequences
of the conflict between these two viewpoints in early America.)
Anne saw herself as a
participant in the power of God and His grace gave her a status that would have
traditionally been determined by that of her husband or father. This social
empowerment was irresistible to her.
The Anglican Church in
England was driven to suppress any preaching or practices that did not conform
to their ideology. The Puritans had already been pressured to relocate to the
new colonies in America starting about 1620. In 1633, John Cotton was removed
from his ministry, threatened with imprisonment, and went into hiding. Soon
after, he departed for the Massachusetts Bay Colony. Anne and William
Hutchinson believed that the Spirit directed them to follow Cotton to the New
World. They had already sent their oldest son along with Cotton.
Anne
Arrives in America
The Hutchinson’s arrived
in Massachusetts with ample assets. They built a house in Boston and bought
farmland outside the town where the city of Quincy is located today. Anne
adjusted easily to her new home. She was a midwife and while attending to the
needs of women in childbirth, she offered them spiritual advice.
A friend of the
Hutchinson’s, John Cotton was now acting as the temporary minister in a church
in Boston. It grew 50% in membership during his first four months, becoming the
leading Puritan church in the city. In her home Anne held gatherings for people
“who had found grace” where she spoke about the teachings of John Cotton. She
also offered her own views and beliefs. Over time her theological
interpretations, closely allied with John Cotton, began to distance her from
the more traditional views of orthodox Puritan ministers in the colony. She
attracted many new followers to the Covenant of Grace including people who
believed that outward behavior was not necessarily tied to one’s soul. Among
the latest visitors to her home was the respected Henry Vane.
But there was religious
tension building between the traditional and new belief systems. The next year,
1634, John Wilson, the permanent and senior pastor of the Puritan church, returned
from England. Anne and other new church members were exposed to his teaching
for the first time. She saw immediately that there was an enormous difference
between her own belief system and his, and it was disagreeable. All the
ministers in the colony, other than John Cotton, believed as Wilson did.
Hutchinson and her co-believers began disrupting Wilson’s sermons or rose and
left the church when he got up to preach. Local ministers began writing to
Cotton communicating their concern over his preaching and about the unorthodox
opinions of his parishioners, especially Anne Hutchinson.
In 1636, new influential
supporters of the Covenant of Grace appeared. The eminent Rev. John Wheelwright arrived
from England and allied himself with Cotton and Hutchinson. He was also Anne’s
brother-in-law. In addition, their supporter Henry Vane had just been elected
Governor. Things were looking up.
But during the summer,
continued disrespect for John Wilson and growing aggression from the Covenant
of Works group caused an eruption between the two factions. In the rear view
mirror of history, we see the Puritans as a single unified sect but nothing
like that existed in 1636 Massachusetts.
Accusations
of Heresy
A Boston magistrate, John Winthrop,
took notice of the turmoil and warned of future actions. Instead of pronouncing
blame on one of the ministers like Cotton or Wheelwright, Winthrop wrote, “One Mrs. Hutchinson, a member of the church
at Boston, a woman of ready wit and a bold spirit, brought over two dangerous
errors: (1) That the person of the Holy Ghost dwells in a justified person; (2)
That no sanctification can help to evidence to us our justification;” in
others words she did not follow the doctrine of the orthodox Puritan church.
Another accusation of her was that she had charged some of the ministers of
preaching a covenant of works; and therefore, they were not proper ministers of
the New Testament.
By late 1636, the schism
had deepened and was called “The Antinomian Controversy.” Hutchinson and her
supporters were accused of two heresies: antinomianism (meaning against or
opposed to the law) and of being familists, the belief that all things are
ruled by nature and not directly by God. Hutchinson, Cotton, Wheelwright, and
Vane were all considered outside the boundaries of the true Puritan church.
Clearly it went beyond a theological debate at this point, and encompassed
gender and political issues as well. The bold behavior of Anne Hutchinson and
her followers had begun to threaten the “Puritan Holy Experiment.”
After
six months of standoffs, things began to change between the Puritan Church and
the followers of the Covenant of Grace. The tide was turning in favor of the
church’s traditional teachings. At this time, there was a very close parallel
between the doctrines of the church and the political actions of the
Massachusetts Bay Colony government; made even closer by the defeat of the
Covenant of Grace supporter, Governor Henry Vane, in the election of May 1637.
He was replaced by John Winthrop, the magistrate who so bitterly condemned Anne
Hutchinson the previous summer.
Anne Hutchinson on Trial
Rev. Wheelwright, Anne’s
brother-in-law, was tried in public court and convicted of provoking a
rebellion against the colony government. He was sentenced to banishment. Other
supporters of Anne were tried and also given similar sentences. But all of this
was just a preface to the main event. In November, Anne Hutchison was brought
to trial on the primary charge of slandering the ministers of the church.
Remember, she had said that they were unfit to teach the New Testament. She was
also charged with “troubling the peace of the commonwealth and churches”
because she promoted opinions that caused distress among the people.
Anne may have been
persecuted to a greater extent because she stepped beyond the gender role that
was considered appropriate for a woman, especially a Puritan woman. The local
ministers were not accustomed to outspoken women, and they saw Anne as a threat
to their position. As she gained more followers, the treat became too much to
tolerate. Her true crime may have been the violation of her role in Puritan
society.
Presiding over her trial
was her nemesis the new Governor, John Winthrop. The goal of the prosecution
was to demonstrate that Anne made denigrating remarks about the ministers. At
first they tried to prove that she had been a co-conspirator of the others
already found guilty. But the court was not able to make that accusation stick.
Her defense was that she had only spoken reluctantly and in private; which was
not completely the case. As the day wore on, Anne was successful at out
maneuvering the arguments of the prosecutors. She possessed boundless self
confidence and was well educated, largely because of her father. At the end of
the first trial day Winthrop said, possibly to atone for his aggressive
questioning, “Mrs. Hutchinson, the court
has labored to bring you to acknowledge the error of your ways.” She
didn’t.
On the trial’s second day,
Anne Hutchinson, buoyed by her triumphs the day before, went on the offensive.
She accused the magistrates and the ministers of violating their own oath of
confidentiality and of deceiving the court about her activities. She also
demanded that the ministerial witnesses testify under oath. Then the court
called John Cotton to the stand. He claimed to remember little of what Anne had
said and done, and tried to portray her in a softer light. But overall his
testimony was less than supportive of this lady who had admired him so much.
Then the most dramatic event
of the trial occurred when Anne addressed the court. Anne’s remarks were
recorded in the transcript as, “You have
no power over my body, neither can you do me any harm - for I am in the hands
of the eternal Jehovah, my Savior. I fear none but the great Jehovah, who has
foretold me of these things, and I do verily believe that he will deliver me
out of your hands. Therefore take heed how you proceed against me - for I know
that, for this you are about to do to me, God will ruin you and your posterity
and this whole state.” It was her chance to teach the court a thing or two,
but ultimately it was her undoing.
Believing Anne to be
possessed by an unholy spirit, the court’s task was now made clearer. Her
outburst was both rebellious and a contempt of court. Winthrop was not going to
allow the assertions of his destructive figure to rewrite the history of the
Massachusetts Bay Colony. John Winthrop moved to have Anne Hutchinson banished.
She was condemned to
banishment “as being a woman not fit for
our society.” Winthrop announced the verdict saying, “It is the Lord’s work, and it is marvelous in our eyes.” Anne was
put under house arrest and not allowed to see her children. She had been
isolated so that others would not be inspired by her words. After four months
of detention, she was put on trial again, this time by the church itself. The
ministers were trying to protect the orthodox doctrine of the Puritan church,
and called Anne forward and read all of the many errors in her interpretation
of the scriptures.
In a heartbreaking turn of
events, John Cotton himself was called upon to deliver the church’s reprimand
of Anne. He said, “It is the overwhelming
conclusion of the ministers that Hutchinson’s unsound beliefs outweighed any
good she has done, and that she endangered the spiritual welfare of the
community . . . Therefore, I do admonish you, and also charge you in the name
of Christ Jesus that you sadly consider the just hand of God against you, the
great hurt you have done to the Churches, the great Dishonor you have brought
to Jesus Christ, and the Evil that you have done to many a poor soul.”
A week later, Anne
Hutchinson was forced to write a formal recantation of her unsound opinions.
She stood in the church that she had attended and, in a subdued voice, read the
denial of her previous beliefs. She admitted that she was wrong about the soul
and the spirit, the resurrection of the body, and in predicting the destruction
of the colony. Most shockingly she agreed that only the Covenant of Works was
the true path to salvation.
Banishment
from Massachusetts
Anne was excommunicated
from the church and given three months to leave the colony. She and her
children travelled to Providence, Rhode Island, at the invitation of Roger Williams,
the founder of that colony. Not long after her family settled there,
Massachusetts made some threats to annex a large portion of Rhode Island which
compelled Anne to move once again, out of the reach of the magistrates and
ministers of the Puritan church. She relocated to New Netherland, now New York
City, after her husband died.
The Hutchinson family’s
timing for their move was regrettable however. In 1643, a band of hostile
Siwanoy warriors attacked the compound where the family lived. They killed all
but one member of the family, cutting off the heads of several then burning the
bodies. One nine-year-old daughter named Susanna was captured and taken to live
with the tribe. Several years later, Susanna was ransomed and returned to other
relatives. It has become known as the Hutchinson Massacre.
After Anne’s death, John
Winthrop wrote, “Thus it had pleased the
Lord to have compassion for his poor churches here, and to discover this great
imposter, an instrument of Satan so fitted and trained to his service of
interrupting the passage of his kingdom in this part of the world, and
poisoning the churches here.”
While her interpretations
of the scriptures were not all that different from mainstream Puritan beliefs,
her criticisms of the prevailing power structure in Massachusetts ultimately
brought her down.
Note
1:
Many literary critics believe that the character of Hester Prynne in
Hawthorne’s “The
Scarlet Letter” was based on Anne Hutchinson’s persecution in
Massachusetts. While Hester Prynne seduced the minister of her community; Anne
Hutchinson was the alleged heretic who seduced the Puritan community. If there
is any real connection between the two, it is more likely that the
fictionalization of Anne Hutchinson was used as the inspiration for the
literary character of Hester.
Note
2:
Anne Hutchinson is also a point of connection between notable people from the
past and notable modern Americans. Her ancestors included Charlemagne, Alfred
the Great, Edward I and Henry II of England, and Eleanor of Aquitaine. Her
descendants include Stephan A. Douglas, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Franklin D.
Roosevelt, George H. W. Bush and George W. Bush, and George Romney and Mitt
Romney.